I wonder if there are two Catherine Elizabeth Judges or did my Catherine have two marriages in 1877, one in May to Paul Carr that you found, Andy, and one in December to my Gt Gt Grandfather, Benjamin George Stone on 22 Dec. 1877 in N.S.W. ?
Her marriage certificate to Benjamin gives her conjugal status as Spinster, but she lied about her age on the marriage certificate and her daughter's birth certificate saying she was full age and 21 years, when she was only 18, so possible she lied saying she was a spinster when she was married.
I think I need to eliminate this Paul Carr as her first husband, to know if my Catherine is the one who who arrived in Adelaide in 1876. The year would be when she would have come.
Thanks everyone for your help.
Lorna