Ambrose EYLES - Collingwood

[enzfan]

Hi

Reply to MAJM

The 1841 death is an uncle Ambrose

Robyn

[alison2763]

Yes it is The Grant Family
Regards
Alison

[sparrett]

Well, It just goes to  further support the statement that there are a lot of very dodgy family trees out there online.

Unfortunately researchers blithely copy large slabs of information from online trees and accomodate them into their own family history. There are no rules that say you can't do this.

No doubt the death of AMBROSE EYLES in COLLINGWOOD MELB. is already a firm fact in someone's history because you have published it as so.

However, we live in the modern communications age and such things will continue to be an issue.

Sue

[enzfan]

Hi

Sorry if I've done something wrong but you will see that where there is doubt I do say so.

If others copy that as gospel then more fool them

Robyn

[sparrett]

If others copy that as gospel then more fool them

Robyn


Quite so!!   

Sue

[enzfan]

Hi Sue

I have removed it because I do appreciate how frustrating it is when others, especially other relations, publish incorrect information.

Hopefully I can put it back when I can confirm Ambrose's parents

Robyn 

[majm]

Hi.

May I ask how do you know that d.c. is for anyones uncle .... please transcribe it.

Cheers JM

[sparrett]

I have removed it because I do appreciate how frustrating it is when others, especially other relations, publish incorrect information.
ROBYN


That is probably for the best


I probably speak for many when I say I  wish more researchers were as thoughtful and conservative in their approach.

Sue

[majm]

Do you have m.c. for Mrs Eyles 2nd marriage .... it MIGHT detail her 1st marriage and issue of that ....   

Very sensible to have removed  ....... you mention poss birth in Adelaide  so you need to get the family from one colony to another before Ambrose death
Cheers  JM