« Reply #10 on: Wednesday 14 August 13 01:05 BST (UK) »
Hi Ambler: I think you may be talking about two different places named Black Carr here. A carr is a topographic feature: a pond or pool; a bog or fen; now, usually, wet boggy ground; a meadow recovered by draining from the bog. There could many of them in the same area, such as in Thornton and Northowram, which are several miles apart.
Interestingly, there is a Brookhouse just to the northwest of Illingworth, which is only a few miles from Thornton. Go to Bing and search Brookhouse, Yorkshire, England. Then click on Maps and you'll see it.
Hope this helps.
John

ENGLAND (all Yorkshire but one)
SLATER: Ovenden, Halifax, and Massachusetts
DOBSON, LONGBOTTOM: Thornton (Bradford)
DRURY: Darton, Halifax, and Massachusetts
NEVIL(LE): Wigan (Lancs.), Darton
MEGSON: Dewsbury, Ossett
GARSIDE: Woolley, West Bretton
SCOTLAND
ROBERT HENDRY: b. 1856, Who-knows-where-shire, Scotland; 1882 to US
DEMPSTER, HOUSTON: Lesmahagow, Glasgow, and Massachusetts
GALBRAITH, MEIKLE: Kirkmichael, Ayr.; Hamilton, Glasgow, and Massachusetts