Sorry about the delay, I had to duck out for a short time. I believe the year of birth 1861 to be correct, as death certificate states he was 74yrs at time of death in 1935. It also does state he was born in Bathurst.
There are also three marriages listed on the DC, no name for the second marriage but as the the other two are correct we know we have the right John Phillips.
The Caroline that has been mentioned I had also reviously thought might be the right, but the year of birth throws it.
miabar, where did you find the death notice, I'm not having luck with it.
Everywhere I have searched never shows a John with right parents.
btw Thanks everyone, you are really helping me with this mystery :-)