Thank you Jackie and Maddie and I must say I am quite touched by your kindness in trying to help me. Unfortunately I am not aware of when Mary Goodman (nee McCarthy) went back to Ireland. It appears that Hubert, my grand father, started his army career at approx aged 18 in 1901. In his list of campaigns it states home August 1901-1902 then he appears to have gone to South Africa. Not sure if home meant in England or in Ireland. Under next akin it lists mother at Dillon Street Clonmel and elder brother George in London. Although underneath it also mentions wife's details. The writing re details of next akin looks similar which may suggest these details were written in retrospect. Hubert didn't marry until 1911, after the 1911 census. In the Ireland 1901 Census the only Goodman family that appeared for Clonmel were living with a John Winchester at Mitchell Street Clonmel. He was a hotel Proprietor from Scotland, a Presbyterian. Strangely, re religious beliefs, he had two Goodman nieces living with him a Lizzie and a Susan one a Presbyterian and one a R/C. Both girls born in Cork City. Not sure if those census details were correct or not. I did search for George junior in London in either 1901 or 1911 and found one with his 1881 birth year working as a hotel porter, born in Ireland, not Rickmansworth! In 1923 June there was a George Goodman aged 42, (my chap would be 41years, birthday July), on the Caronia Ship Port Liverpool England. He appeared to be working on the ship and he was there again in July. I also tried, without success, looking up the 1901 census for Cashel Co Tipperary as I wondered if Margaret McCarthy, mother of Mary Goodman was still in William street where she was with her grandchild Theresa Gertrude when she died there in 1888. I am amazed to see how many Goodman names were in Ireland, mainly the north, in the 1901 census 364 of them if I am interpreting it correctly.