Hello Suznor, I've only just found this message. John Baldwin Theobald was my ggg grandfather.
I have been spending a fair bit of time trying to find why he went to NZ.
Some of the other links and messages were to do with me. The one from Adele who mentioned the burial ground at Castlepoint, was from her helping me.
Like you, I had found the newspaper death notice of John dying in 1869. I havent had any luck finding a death certificate, or an immigration record.
But I do believe the J Theobald on the sign at the cemetery gate at Castlepoint is our John Theobald.
The death date that is on many trees is incorrect, of course it is taken because William mentioned it in his biography, but we all know how incorrect family stories are!
John's nephew Edward John Barnett, the son of his sister Ann Theobald and Isaac Barnett, also moved to NZ and married and died there. The thing is, I had found an immigration record about 1873 for Edward which was after John had died, but most interesting is that around 1880 Edward was a store manager at Castlepoint. Which is a decade after John died. Which makes me wonder whether there was any family left behind there........
The last record of John in England was in the 1861 census:
1861 10 Ebenezer Bldgs Shoreditch
John Theobald, head, mar, 51, Ironmoulder, Isle of Wight
Ann Theobald, wife, mar, 49, Essex Stratford
William Theobald, son, 16, laborer, Shoreditch
George Theobald, son, 9, scholar, Shoreditch
Charles Theobald, son, 7, scholar, Shoreditch
I havent bought the death certificate of Ann so dont know if the one in Shoreditch in 1869 was the correct one.
I have ordered a book called 'Castlepoint' from NZ in the hope of finding some history about the place.
Cheers