Did you look into the marriage of a Matthew Welsh ( Christiana Price/ Ellen Taylor on page)1858 MarchQ. in Hunslet district (covers a portion of Leeds) There is a John born Hunslet 1862...just in case he (#1 husband Robert) was using a middle name? Was hoping to find some christenings online for actual couple but unsuccessful. This middle name thing happened with my family, and it makes searching a real pain...so thought I'd point out middle name use ( like Edward / Edwin ) in case you hadn't enough junk to sort through (Just kidding, hope this doesn't throw you off too much)
Found this on the tweedybird site:
WELCH Robert, age 13, 4 years in Canada, with Mr William H Graham of Stayner. ( that's in Simcoe)
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~tweetybirdgenealogy/jul1896.htmlso by 1901 his contract would have been finished with Graham...They were indentured to age 18 if you can believe it. Just children and had to sign a contract of such a nature. I hope Graham was at least a decent man... ... but little wonder these young ones had little or no memory of parents when they were put under such stress to work at an age they should have been playing. At least some families were kind and sharing, but some BHC had it pretty tough, at a dollar a month pay.
Seems the John Welch (Clara Adams) were from Stratford, so probably the right fellow from the CEF signup...
( marriage of a son, b. Gravesend England 1902)
http://homepages.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~maryc/perth1924.htmp.s. re: Polar Bear's marriage find
seems to rule them out...however...although he says he was born England I see no marriage of a John Welch/Welsh (phonetic surname search on) to an Emma Monroe on the freeBMD, and removing forenames, no Munroe/ Monroe/Welch /Welsh combinations either....
and daughter born St Geo.H. Sq. 1908
http://homepages.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~maryc/perth1927.htmGo figure the birth of the son is registered in England and Ontario? Thomas Lewis Welch
Oct 26 1902 McKillop Township, Huron, Ontario, Canada [John Welch & Clara Adams] also reg DecQ. Gravesend
arghhh, how can we prove/disprove this to be John?