Hi JM and Sue,
You two are troopers, from your latest work I now have John Cates daughter's marraige and the reason for Kain and Collier middle names. To date I have John Cates surgeon's children as Elizabeth Ann 1832, William John born 1833, Henry EDIT
:
Joseph in 1834, Humphrey Gwynne 1838/9, George Collier, 1840, Susan Kain 1844 and my link James Samuel born 1852 and of course the enigma Charles Collier Cates

?.
In respect of Charles Augustus Cates I read all your posts as saying he was born in Queensland in 1890 , put into Randwick Asylum with sister Elizabeth Ann in 1895 then joined up in 1915 saying he was born Dunedin in New Zealand when in fact he wasnt. served with Camel Corp in Greece, and Abysinnia,discharged medically unfit Oct 1916. Then reenlisted with AIF 1917 and discharged Mar 1919. The added bonus is the photo, wonderful.
Also more news of the Richardsons is superb.
Many thanks
Terry