In another muddle, help please.......

[Helina]

Thanks for your help and advice.  I heartly agree with you about accepting information from familytrees, especially on ancestry reason I never keep mine on that site.

Siblings to Ethel Mary are

Joyce Elsie b 1899
Joseph James b 1902
Gertrude Ellen b 1905
Edith Marie b 1907

helina

[danuslave]

From A**y

birth registrations

Edith Marie Neale 1907 Jan-Feb-Mar Thornbury Vol 6a Page 249

Ethel Mary Neale 1909 Oct-Nov-Dec Thornbury Vol 6a Page 239

from family search

baptism/christening

Edith Mary Neale  25 Jan 1907  Olveston
Father  Charles James Neale
Mother  Ellen Florence

Ethel Mary Neale  02 Jan 1910  Olveston
Father  Charles James Neale
Mother  Ellen Florence

So it looks as though family search has got Edith's middle name wrong

Linda 

[esdel]

The two first names are different and distinct, far more then Mary vs Marie
If I were you I'd assume two different people until you have collected far more info on each and verified it by means that you have reason to think are independent of each other.
esdel

[danuslave]

Hi esdel

Obviously didn't make myself clear 

I was trying to show that I thought they were 2 separate people, but sisters.

Given Tati's previous post, I think Helina's best bet would be to check the 1911 census

Linda

[esdel]

Oh sorry, I misunderstood, was confused.

Now I understand - I agree!

What a turncoat, eh!
esdel

[Helina]

Thanks again.   

So it looks as though family search has got Edith's middle name wrong


I do not think neceessary so, on my father's side he had 5 Aunts,   3 where called Eleanor Eliza, Elizabeth Kate and Eliza Ann.    Maybe they liked the name Mary/Marie.

I,ve searched the 1911 index found Ethel Neale born 1910 so gather the 1909 birth might be correct. note no middle name which would of been helpfull.

Thanks again

helina

[kerry1212]

this usually happens when 1 child dies they name the next the same

just a thought

kerry

[Helina]

Thanks a idea, kerry, should of thought of that.  I'll have a search in the 1911 index for a Edith.

Thanks

helina