Hi Deb,
Thanks for your help. The marriage that you have found is the right one.
Robert and Elizabeth's children were:
Gay Shute c1778 Poole, Dorset - 1852 Gosport, Hampshire
Sophia Shute bc1779
Jonathan Fowler Shute b & d 1782
Jonathan Shute c1784 Poole, Dorset - Living 1861 Oswestry, Shropshire
Fowler Shute c1789 - d by 2 May 1812 Cape Town, South Africa
Robert Shute was Supervisor of the Excise for Poole District from 13 Jul 1774 - 1 Jun 1785, so it is assumed that all the children were born there. Gay and Jonathan identified Poole as their place of birth in the census returns. I have not however found the actual entries of baptism. I am not sure what happened to Sophia, but both Sophia and Fowler were living in 1792 when their grandfather Benjamin Gay wrote his Will. Fowler died as a naval officer in Cape Town. If he was born as late as 1789, he could have been born in Cornwall or Devon, depending on where his father was based for the Stratton Ride.
I know nothing of Robert Shute's first marriage nor to whom he was married.
Kind regards,
Stephen