Hi
We clearly have some confusions between two men here and Debra has clarified it. I will add my thoughts too.
The burial of the man at KARRAKATTA which I have transcribed below, is the man referred to in the newspaper (by the date and specific location advised in the notice.)
The cemetery has his name as with ROBERT as a second given, but the newspaper notice omits this.
The BDM index has him as Chares R Smith or East Perth aged 23.
Also on the index is CHARLES SMITH without (R) of York. Same year
I see no burial for this second man at KARRAKATTA.
Therefore,I would think we can disregard the CHARES ROBERT and the newspaper notice as not being your man.
Do you agree ?
CHARLES ROBERT SMITH
Aged 23 Date 22/12/1907 Of EAST PERTH
Grave Location
KARRAKATTA CEMETERY WESLEYAN AA 0036A
http://www.mcb.wa.gov.au/NameSearch/search.phphttp://www.bdm.dotag.wa.gov.au/_apps/pioneersindex/default.aspxDebra: Yes I have his marriage certificate and parents names. But what I NEED to find out about is this story that he was a 'topnotch' violinist! (I'm working on the theory that someone in the tree must know something about his early life in Australia...) Scottfive
ScottFive, It is
possible that someone with the first hand knowledge you seeking willl turn up , but as researchers--unrelated to your people--, we can only help by starting with what we can find on your family and, moving forward (and sideways etc.).
We hope that the path will lead to an answer.
Sue