Hi Plonker
sorry don't have Williams birth cert, so cant comment.
Although perhaps not your direct line - this birth cert may be important to sorting out Catherine and why she is using the name TOWNSEND, also to see if son William was registered illigitimate or as the son of Paul TOWNSEND. May be proved wrong - but I'm picking there'll be no father on the cert and that the address of William's birth may be that of his grandparents MILLINGTON.
i have son Thomas marriage cert which lists father as Paul Townsend.
Catherine's sons' Marriages:
1895: MARRIAGE William TOWNSEND, married Ellan Ann ROSE, Pontefract - and on the certificate stated his father to be "Paul TOWNSEND" (other topic)
18??: MARRIAGE: Thomas TOWNSEND and ??. Marriage cert states father is Paul TOWNSEND (cert)
1897: MARRIAGE: John TOWNSEND age 21 (b abt 1876) , son of Paul TOWNSEND married Sarah Ellen BAKER 19, dau of Robert BAKER at Feathertone, Yorkshire (searchlabs)
1899: MARRIAGE: Paul TOWNSEND and Emma Elizabeth WALL, Pontefract (freebmd). They are on the Census in Castlefod 1901 - where he says pob Pendlebury Lancs.
http://search.labs.familysearch.org/recordsearch/start.html#startSo that's 3 out of 4 of them at least, who gave their father as "Paul TOWNSEND" - which indicates there was a real-life man they knew to be their father, named "Paul", if not with the surname "TOWNSEND" (see next).
i have looked at the other posts and am still confused as to who he was and where he came from.
I am still looking for proof that Paul Townsend ever existed.
I think there is compelling evidence that his surname was STANLEY, which won't be too hard to prove:
I also found this topic by another chatter, same family:
http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php/topic,311231.msg1925888.html#msg1925888Reading that topic, together with the other two, and searching through census, BMD, and Search labs - I can't see anyone else more likely to be "Paul TOWNSEND" than Paul STANLEY, born in Bilston Staffs to Thomas and Fanny STANLEY :
1881:70 Grosvenor St - Village of Newtown, Worsley, Barton on Irwell, LancashireRG11 / Piece: 3878 / Folio: 83 / Page: 36
Head: Paul STANLEY 38, Coal Miner, b Bilston Staffs
Wife: Emma STANLEY 32, b Bilston Staffs
Step-Son: William TOWNSEND 11, Scholar, b High Fields Staffs
Son: Thomas STANLEY 8, b St Helens Lancashire
Son: John STANLEY 5, b Clifton Lancashire
Son: Paul STANLEY 2, b Worsley LancashireDau: Alice Ann STANLEY 9 weeks, b Worsley, Lancashire
Mother: Fanny STANLEY 78, widow, b Weyebury, Staffordshire (Wednesbury?)
Boarder: James J? STANLEY 27, unm, Coal Miner, b Dudley Worcestershire
Boarder: Matthew COULEY 40, unm, Coal Miner, b Ireland
1888: MARRIAGE - Catharine TOWNSEND and William CHURN, reg in Pontefract Yks - both on same page.
1891: CENSUS Whitwood, Castleford, YksRG12 / Piece: 3762 / Folio 73 / Page 27
Head: William CHURM 41, Coal Miner, b Bilston Staffs
Wife: Catherine CHURM 41, b Sedgeley Staffs
Son: David CHURM 18, b Pendleton Lancs
Son: William CHURM 12, Pendleton Lancs
Son: Samuel CHURM 11, b Pendleton Lancs
Dau: Florence CHURM 3, b Whitwood
Step-Son: William TOWNSEND 20 , b Sedgeley Staffs
Step-son: Thomas TOWNSEND 18, b Clifton Lancs
Step-Son: John TOWNSEND 15, b Clifton Lancs
Step-Son: Paul TOWNSEND 12, b Clifton LancsHighfields, in the village of Ettingshall, Sedgley - is where Catherine's mother Ann was with her own parents in 1841.
Is Emma STANLEY in 1881 above, really Catharine ?
One way to try prove or disprove - is the birth cert of the new-born daughter, enumerated as "Alice Ann".
There is no registration for an "Alice Ann" in Barton-upon-Irwell (the district covering Worsley) - but there is this one:
BIRTH: Philis Ann STANDLEY 1881; and she later died 1883 age 2 (registered as STANLEY)
Catherine had an older sister named Philis in the 1861 Census (and who may have died in Dec Qtr 1861). If Philis Ann STANDLEY's 1881 birth cert shows her mother as Catharine, then the 1881 Census is either a mistake in naming her "Emma" or they were deliberately hiding her identity?
There is also this - which I'm betting is Catherine's son Paul "TOWNSEND".
BIRTH: Paul STANDLEY - Sep Qtr 1878, Barton (upon Irwell) Lancs
Cheers
AMBLY