This would appear to be Helen with her family on the 1881 census . Note Helens brothers occupation.
Dwelling: 13 Moray Street
Census Place: Edinburgh St Cuthberts, Edinburgh, Scotland
David PHILIPS. M, 54 , M, Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland. Head
Occ: Shoemaker
Janet PHILIPS. M, 54 , F,Edinburgh, Scotland.
Rel: Wife
John PHILIPS. U, 19, M,Edinburgh, Scotland
Rel: Son. Occ: Surgical Instrument Maker
Janet PHILIPS. 15, F, Edinburgh, Scotland
Rel: Daur. Occ: Dressmaker
Helen PHILIPS. 13, F, Edinburgh, Scotland
Rel: Daur. Occ: Scholar