Irene, I just thought to post on here what I have sent you in case anyone is researching this family in the future. Elizabeth Clark MacDonald looks to have joined her husband with her children in New York in 1929. Likely entry for the family on the 1930 US census in Newark, Essex, New Jersey:
Robert Macdonald 39
Elizabeth Macdonald 38
Andrew Macdonald 19
Elizabeth Macdonald 17
Robert Macdonald 15
Grace Macdonald 13
David Macdonald 11
Agnes Macdonald 8
John Macdonald 5
All the children showing as born in Broxburn, West Lothian or Edinburgh (Grace).
Monica
