Doesn't the marriage record note the father's occupation ? (I know this is pre-1837, but some church records did).
The marriage record will be one of those 3-to-a-page things which doesn't even mention parents - I really hate those!
One thing's for certain, jayjay, you can't just pick one you like the sound of - not if you're serious about your family tree. For all you know at this stage there might be a third or fourth option you've not found yet

It is like a jigsaw, as Panda says, and the fun is in finding the right fit - and it's a buzz when you do.
Christine