burials at St Mary's Bramall Lane:
STARR Abraham 19 Apr 1852 11y Rockingham St
STARR Ann 8 Jul 1874 63y Upperthorpe
STARR Charles 25 Jan 1866 25y Division St
STARR Olive 20 Jun 1854 8y Division St
STARR Thomas 6 Feb 1870 39y Brightside
[name/date of burial/age/residence]
Since this Abraham was only 11, maybe he is a son of the Abraham born 1812. Are you confusing his death entry for the older Abraham? (or maybe his age is an error)
Hugh