It looks to me like the Shermans, both Thomas and Charles, were associated with St Cuthberts in Halsall, as most (but not all) the Parish records seem to turn up there. There is also a William and a Henry Sherman who had growing families at the same time, and an Elizabeth who was a single woman who had babies baptised at St Cuthberts.
I'd traced the following who may have been their children:
Mary bapt. 1829
Henry bapt. 1833
William bapt.1837
Elizabeth bapt.1846
Elizabeth bapt.1848
William bapt. 1850
Alice bapt. 1841
Thomas in my family tree seems to have lived in various villages in the area - Melling, Snape Green in Scarisbrick, Aughton and finally, Burscough.
A single woman named Alice Sherman had the following children baptised at St Cuthberts:
James - 1869
Mary 1873
Margaret 1876
Martha 1881
In 1881, Alice is living at Morris Lane with two of these children and her mother, Ellen - it seems this is the Alice Sherman who was Thomas Sherman's daughter, however.
And I have the following burials, which might be Charles and Margaret:
Burial: 20 Aug 1881 St Mark, Scarisbrick, Lancashire, England
Margaret Sherman -
Age: 74 years
Abode: Scarisbrick
Burial: 10 Dec 1881 St Mark, Scarisbrick, Lancashire, England
Charles Sherman -
Age: 82 years
Abode: Scarisbrick
A good rummage in
www.lan-opc.org.uk should turn up a lot of Shermans who appear to be related to one another - there still are and always have been a lot of them around that area. I've still not managed to distinguish them all from one another but it should be possible! My feeling is that if Thomas and Charles were brothers, then their parents moved at some point from Rufford to Scarisbrick/Halsall.