Hi,
Is this the Sarah that married John Tinker in 1844 at Manchester Cathedral? If you obtain her marriage certificate it would give you the name of her father.
There is a possible baptism for a Sarah Chesnall on the 22nd July, 1821 at the Cathedral. Parents were William Chesnall and Ann. Also the baptism of Johnson Chesnall on the 8th November, 1818 with the same parents. Johnson being with the rest of the family on the 1841 census although by then he was married to Margaret.
From
www.lan-opc.org.uk:
Marriage: 10 Jul 1815 Collegiate, Manchester, Lancashire, England
William Chesnall - (X), Tobaconnist Batchelor of this Parish and Town of Manchester
Ann Crompton - (X), Spinster of this Parish and Town of Manchester
Witness: John Beard; Benj Ball
Married by Banns by: John Gatliff Fellow
Like I say you will need Sarahs marriage to confirm it, but the above is worth putting on the backburner just in case.
Regards,
Mo