Hi GEM,
There does seem to be a birth of a John Sherliker in Hindley in 1839 (HNDL/1/361) but where does he vanish to? I can't find a corresponding family in 1841 and he also doesn't seem to have died, at least not in the Wigan area. There was also a John Sherliker born in Preston in 1842. So "would the real John Sherliker please stand up?" (Do you know the old TV show?) I don't know why he was born in Preston on his marriage certificate and on Nelly's birth certificate, but born in Hindley in the 1881 census. Perhaps he grew up in Preston, but then remembered that he had been told he was born in Hindley....whatever! . By the way in 1861, a 22-yearold John Sherliker born in Preston - fits in with 1839 - was lodging in PRESTWICH cum Oldham in Burns Street.
The Catherine Sherliker who died in Liverpool died in the Jan/Feb/Mar quarter. Why do you think she was not John's wife? There does not seem to be anyone born Catherine Sherliker in Liverpool in the period in question and there was no Sherliker marriage to a Catherine. The only Sherliker marriage in Liverpool between 1868 and 1931 that I can find is of a Herbert Sherliker to Cecilia Laffey. So here's my new story:
The young couple wanted to better themselves and set up a butcher's shop in Liverpool. Tragically the young wife died and the husband was forced to return home and work as a tin smith again. My g.g.grandfather (the one with the two Elizabeths) 's brother was a coal miner with no education until he suddenly became a tea dealer and in 1901 was living in a 7-bedroomed house near Mesnes Park in Wigan. Pity my own g.g.grandfather didn't show similar initiative. He continued living seven in a room in a hovel in Scholes!!
My story is substantiated by the fact that Catherine Hickman vanishes after this, and I can't find a marriage for her. Also she was supposedly born in 1850, which actually ties in better with the death date of Catherine Sherliker in 1914. The irritating thing is that although she claims to have been born in Wigan in the 1871 census, I can't find a birth. She could, of course, have been married at 18 and widowed at 20, but like Lily, she is rather elusive. If Catherine Hickman does turn out to be the mother, it's going to be almost impossible to trace her back! I know quite a bit about the Bambers/Sherrys.
I am stumped with Lily and very, very frustrated. I don't think there's a spelling of Sherliker/Selecar/Shirliker/Shorliker/Shalliker etc. that I haven't tried. But don't forget we are dealing with transcriptions. It must be quite hard transcribing page after page of names and quite easy to overlook an entry. I don't know whether it is possible to access the original records in Wigan and look through all the records for 1884 -1887. Perhaps you can pay for a professional search. I don't know whether it is worth that much to you or your friend. I know they do searches in Ireland, but they are quite expensive. Let's keep our fingers crossed with John James Selkir(k)! The other possibility is baptism records. I'm sure most children were christened at the time. If they were Catholics as the Sherrys were, then I'd look for St Joseph's records. If the children were CofE, the I'd look at the records of St Thomas in Wallgate. This is where John Sherliker and Catherine Bamber apparently married.
I think perhaps Lily was at home in 1901. The census takers had loads to do and were dealing with people who couldn't read or write. They probably told a confused story. Nelly and Lily don't sound too different. I think the census taker started writing down Nelly's details and ended up with Lily's date of birth, i.e. he made one sister out of two. Stranger things have happened in these censuses. I correspond with a descendent of the Sherrys who is totally confused because one of the daughters married a McDonnell and they appear on various certificates as McDonnell or McDonald, which makes it really difficult to know whether you are dealing with the right family.
Keep me informed,
Linda