I am still focussing on sealing crew McNallys ( and derivatives) prior to 1819- so futher to Post 346 we have John Macanally as crew per Gov Maquarie 13/8/1814, John Macanally per Gov Maquarie 4/3/1815, James Macanally alias Wilson per Perserverance with Catharine Rooke in 1811, and of course the John McNally and wife employed by Cummings 6/1/1816 per Brothers.
Just from memory, Owen is out of the frame, so is Patrick.
I can't get out of my mind that we have two guys called Mcnally, John and James , in Port Dalrymple in 1818 , a seaman John Mcnally on the Governor Maquarie who pops up in Sydneyand Hobart between 1810-1818 at least, a John Mcnally and a Catherine having a child in 1810, and a John McNally and wife going to Port Dalrymple 1816. I have checked my notes, but can't see why I eliminated Catherine Rook(e) from the scene- daughter of William Rooke? did she die in the Boyd massacre, was she just too old- otherwise there she is in the same crew as James Macanally in the Perserverance in 1810 ( and John on Rosetta with William Rooke as master in 1815)
David