The Morrison famly need to followed up and one wonders if there was a link between Ransom and Morrison back in England.
Like Wiggy I believe if C.C. McNally is not a convict because had she been a convict lass she would have been accounted for, from her sentence through to her demise.
So we are left with possible origins:
1) Free settler as a single woman, widow or a daughter. (?Carribean fit here)
2) Soldier/marine's abandoned wife, widow, daughter. (Carribean story would fit)
3) Camp follower (unlikely due to her good reputation in VDL) (Carribean story would fit)
4) Government official's abandonded wife. (unlikely it woul dhave been in the papers)
5) Colonial born convict's child.
6) Ransom's daughter or step daughter. (Carribean story would possibly fit)
It says a lot about social attitudes of the times that free women were so often recorded merely as "Mrs So and So" or "and wife".
At the present time, I'm leading towards Catharine giving birth to Thomas McNally outside of VDL and thus not arriving in VDL until shortly after the 1822 muster ... to me, that's the most logical reason she's not found on that 1822 Muster.
Fits all the above.
modified to addI thought Wiggy had sighted the baptismal regisration and it was in 1820 not 1829? Need her to advice on this point.
Robyn