Hi good to see the old thread wake up
Now this is my present take on the situation its full of folk not waiting for the vicar's blessing

which complicates the situation
Starting with Caroline FROUD (1809) she had Esther FROUD in 1834
Caroline then married James Belcher 4 Jun 1835
After that Esther was known as Belcher until she married John LEE in 1858 as Esther FROUD
but Esther had a son Walter in 1855 before she married
WALTER is registered as Walter FROUD no mother's surname on the GRO index
On the 1851 census he is Walter F (Froud?)Belcher living with his Grandparents as their son
1961 Walter BELCHER is with his uncle Henry Belcher (Henry was a son of James Belcher and Caroline Froud)
Walter married as BELCHER and gave his father as James Belcher not surprising as his Grandfather James had bought him up
Now as it happens there were two Walter Belchers in the area both born in 1856 one in Wantage District mother maiden name East and one in Abingdon district mother maiden name Sandbrook