Thurlstone became a separate parish from Penistone in 1906. Somewhat surprising, because there is evidence of settlement in Thurlstone predating settlement in Penistone, where the church dates from 12th century. For about 50 years before St Saviour's Church, Thurlstone was built in 1905, Anglican worship was in the Church School at Townend, but baptisms, marriages and funerals would have been in Penistone, which served an area of about 50 square miles.
I know others are researching HINCHLIFF(E) and HINCHCLIFF(E) in the Penistone area.
One branch of the HINCHLIFFE family worshipped in Netherfield Chapel and went there for marriages and burials.
Sam