hi tati,it's all so confusing,on the 1871 census it says ann brooks is his mother,i sent for his marriage certificate when he married my great gran in 1886 but there is no father on it thanks anyway tati
I don't think the 1871 says anything other than Samuel Joseph is grandson to Joseph Fokinther.
Is it possible that Samuel Joseph was the son of one of the other girls? Then he could be John Brooks' nephew.
I can't find Mathilda or Jane Fokinther in the 1871 census, can you? Did they marry or what? The youngest seems to be a servant in Brimington in 1871, aged 19 - she is rather young to be mother of Samuel Joseph but not impossible I suppose - Brimington is a spit from Chesterfield.
So how about Samuel Joseph was son of one of Ann's sisters, lived with his grandparents in 1871 and then with Ann in 1881? Perhaps his mother died or his stepfather didn't want him, or it was better for work.