Could Susannah b. ca. 1828-1830, been married three times? In 1861 she and James Atkinson were the parents of Bryan. In 1881 Bryan is the son of John and Susannah ?elton (what is that first letter?) and in 1891 Bryan's daughter Susannah is living with Henry and Susannah Holmes.
Also where was 5 year old Ben Atkinson living in 1901?
Who was the mother of Josephina b.ca. 1900?
Sorry to be a pest but you all have been so helpful it just leads to more questions.