Hi,
Was drawn to the topic with surname as I have similar but from South Uist. Anyway, no surprise re mix-up, with the grand total of about 5 forenames to choose from in those days

I have similar, 3 Donalds, 2 with different middle names, all brothers, not MacInnes though!!!!
Anyway, enjoyed the read and just a thought (yes, a thought) :-
The fact that "Maggie" seems to have been shunned/banished - was she possibly the outcome of extra curricular activity??

Regards,
Anne