Hi again
The Catherine, b. Ramsay, looks pretty, good

John Mctavish was, I'm pretty certain having looked at SP,etc. and his age, born Skipness, Argyll so it's worth tracing his parents, Donald McTavish and Catherine McArthur~
They married in Sadell and Skipness 27th April 1850
Following children to the couple - all Sadell and Skipness:
20 April 1851 - Catherine
7 March 1853 - John
5 August 1855 - Mar(r)ion
28 Sept 1865 - Hector
1861:
Saddell Castle, Saddell, 2Argyll
Reg Dist 531/1 ED 1 Page 2
McTavish Donald, 49, Herdsman
Catherine,39
Catherine,10
John, 8
Sarah, 5
Mary, 3
Ann (9), 1, b. Saddell
All others born Skipness
I've had a quick look on the 1871 but can't spot them straight away.I'll have another look later.
Gadget