Hello Brett,
My husband has the McGeorge family in his line, and also the Baxter name. That part comes from a John McGeorge who married a Jean Baxter in Urr, Kirkcudbright, Scotland way back in the early 1800s. The McGeorge name was to be found still being used as a middle name as late as the 1890s. I wonder what the connection is with the Baxters? My husband's line of descent is through an Elizabeth McGeorge born to John McGeorge and Jean Baxter in Urr, Kirkcudbright in 1807. It is also interesting that one of Elizabeth's brothers, William McGeorge born 1816 in Urr, went to Liverpool in England and married there, had two children and they then all migrated to NSW around 1853. William McGeorge died in NSW in 1897, so I wonder if there is a connection? By the way, we also live in Victoria!
Anne