Jax,
I am not quite sure where we are going with this

but, for what it's worth, I have found the Tingle family from the IGI in East Dean in 1851.
MATTHEWS William Lodger Widow/er 44 East Dean
William Lodger 14 Short Standing
TINGLE Dinah Servant 20 East Dean
TINGLE Thomas 45 unmarried Coal Miner East Dean
William 23 Coal Miner Brother East Dean
Geo Brother 15 Coal Miner East Dean
BENNETT Benjamin Visitor 22 Farmers son East Dean
ROLAND Mary Visitor Married 25 Dressmaker Derbyshire Peters
The age for Thomas has to be wrongly transcribed - he has aged 20 years! - Diana has become Dinah.
Nothing is proved yet - but - I am going to search East Dean on the 1861. If I find this William we will know he is not yours - cos your William is in Staffs then!
I'll be back!
Darcy