Hi Malc,
Well, it certainly isn't straight-forward, is it!
It seems strange to think that a couple named
both of their daughters Charlotte - or have I got that bit wrong! Or, did you mean
sister-in-laws. (no, maybe not!)
I could understand that - if the first one died; but not if both were living!

I think it's more likely that they are two, or more, Thomas Richards around in Nottingham at this time (well you know already that there are two married to Elizabeths) But, like you, I can only find
one baptism for a Charlotte Richards with a father named Thomas

Is the information with regard to the father's names from the marrigage certificates, Malc? Do either say Thomas Richards, deceased (of did that come in later? Maybe it did) Still think it's strange there is only one marriage bond/licence - perhaps there is another marriage licence in Derbyshire,
or somewhere else.
I also wonder if the first Charlotte Richards died in another area, Malc. (perhaps if her father was the one who died in Hoxton (*see further on), that that
might explain one part of the puzzle).
Anyway, this is the information on Thomas Richards:
Universal British Directory, 1791 -98
Corporation
Esquires. Members in Parliament
Mr Thomas Richards + Mr Henry Green jnr. Chamberlains
+ later .....
Richards, Thomas
hosier1815 Sutton's Nottingham Directory
Richards, Thomas hosier Castle-gate
1825 Glover's Nottingham Directory
Senior Council
And also of the Livery or Clothing Burgesses
Mr. Thomas Richards, London
3 references to him also come up on google booksearch if you put in Thomas Richards Nottingham:
The Nottm Date Book
P.349 1819
Politics and Society in Nottingham P. 116 1825
Parliamentary Papers 1843 P.29
*Nothing spectacular there.
There
is a will on NA:
11 July, 1840 Will of Thomas Richards, late Silk Merchant of Haberdashers Place, Hoxton, Middlesex PRO 11/1931
* can't see any Charlotte mentioned
(bought it in case it was connected with my lot, but as I thought it isn't - writing is
so fuzzy, but I'm almost certain no Charlotte is mentioned, Malc).
So, in my opinion I not sure this one was Charlotte's father - unless it was Charlotte Mk 1's father, and where is her birth + what age was this one! (
so complicated, isn't it!)
To have been a burgess,
and a Chamberlain in 1791 this Thomas Richards must I think have born before 1770, because of the age of finishing his apprenticeship. Pity we don't know his age at death - I suppose it
will say on the death certificate, in 1840.
But, I did find several interesting things on NA site:
www.rootschat.com/links/05pmwww.rootschat.com/links/05ppThere is a lot to look through, Malc, but you will see that George Graham Chappell is mentioned .
Now, I could be getting this completely wrong, but it looks as if this Elizabeth, wife of Thomas Richards, remarried in 1816, to Joseph Burbage, at Nottm St Mary. So, this, Elizabeth Burbage, has the mother of Charlotte Mk 2.
Anyway, Malc, see what conclusion you come to, and let me know. As I said I may have it all completely upside down, and I won't be at all offended if you say so. It doesn't by any means answer all of the questions but it may give a bit of a glimpse into some of it.
Bye for now.
Paulene
Sorry - I know it's going to take a bit to get your head round all of this

Perhaps I've so much time on all this my brain has become a bit addled - wouldn't surprise me

Sheila, please feel free to say what
you think

We could do with some help!
Malc, I can email you the will if you want to see it youserlf - you, too, Sheila.