Hello
Glad to have been able to pass the information on.
@Seahall - I know from our past communication how much your friendship with Patti meant to you, and it's lovely that you remember her often. I think I remember you saying how surprised she was to see herself as a young girl in one of the wedding photos I sent you, and I'm sure you will have many memories of her.
My great, great grandmother was Agnes Gwynne [c1854 - 1912], the daughter of James and Betsy. I think it's wonderful that 100 years after she died, family connections are still being made, as these unexpected contacts are a part of this hobby that I really enjoy.
I meant to say in my email yesterday that I think I may have found a brother of James Gwynne living nearby in Airdrie.
A William Gwin [indexed by ScotlandsPeopl as GUIM], aged 27 married Margaret Grant, a 27 year old widow, on 11th August 1857 at Airdrie. William was a Miner, and gave his parents as William Gwin, Soldier, and Matilda Gwin [no other maiden name given]. Margaret's parents were Walter Grant and Margaret Millar. Interesting, Walter is show as "dead", but no such annotation is given for William's parents, indicating that he must have known or believed that they were still alive at that point.
Tracing them through the 1861 Census at Slamannan (where, inexplicably, William is recorded as William Thornton), and 1871 (Greengairs, New Monkland) William is recorded as born in Ireland.
William dies on 14th March 1880 at Baird's Rows, Bothwellpark, and on his death record his father is recorded as William Gwynne, Coal Miner, [deceased], with no mother's details provided. I haven't traced Margaret Grant's death yet, but in 1881 she has moved to East Lothian and is working as a Farm Servant, with adult daughters Martha, aged 19, and Elizabeth, aged 17. All three are indexed by Ancestry as GUIEN.
This doesn't add anything re the birthplace discussion for William / Matilda or James / Betsy, but I thought the potential link to William Gwynne who married in 1857 at Airdrie and the reference to his father being a soldier was interesting to mention.
Best wishes
Brian