I am most likely in the wrong place, but seeing that you are talking about churches l will just ask this question---
Looking on the marriage certificate of my gtgtgrandfather Reubon Bodfish and Sarah Holloway on December 25 1874, l see the church mentioned as the Parish Church of st Matthews or st Matthies, birmingham, in the county of Warwick. It is said that they eloped as he at least came from Todmarton, in Oxfordshireshire, and Sarah gave her age as 18, but its thought she was only 16. If anyone knows anything about the church l would love to hear from them. thanks pam