That might be him aged 32 in 91 Susan - He is married, though b Padstow - the other one wasn't married by then. (whichever one this is looks like he is lying)

Being seamen they keep vanishing and reappearing.
1901 can be explained I think
A Mark BATE aged 49 is listed aboard the "Rhodesia" arriving Sydney 29 Apr 1901. OriginI think is Padstow - Port of Departure Pt Elizabeth (South Africa)
Both Mark's, Ellen and Anna were all buried in Padstow (Burial for Anna in agreement with a 1856 birth)
Cheers Kris
