Mary Marshall Whose Daughter?

[caroclay]

hi margaret

my g grandfather was james stewart marshall
son of james marshall
who was the son of stewart martin marshall

who in turn was the son of william marshall & agnes adam

they are such a large family it is amazing how many desendants are all on here

as judy said we should have a marshall reunion/meeting

[alex m]

Hello Judy / Mouse 2, Please send emails for the photos.               Regards .......................Alex

[alex m]

Hello Judy and Mouse2, Have you got those photos yet?                   Regards......................Alex

[ankerdine]

With apologies, Alex, of course I received them and thank you very much indeed for taking the trouble to e-mail them.

Been trying to sort out my OHs gt grandfather's wife and parents in deepest Shropshire meantime.

Kindest regards

Judy

[Auchencrieff]

I would agree that Mary is the daughter. The family are complicated and they don't seem to age as the age always changes.
William married Margaret Neil. Other members of the family were Robert who married Esther Stanhope.
Perhaps we are related.

[ankerdine]

Sometimes I wonder if I am in my right mind!

You see I have a William Marshall who is on the 1841 census with Alexander Marshall (brother of Robert Marshall who married Esther Stanhope) at Creetown born c1828. I have him marrying a Mary Jane O'Neil born Stranraer. This is not the same chap as yours. I think all first-born Marshalls were namedWilliam!!!

If I post a photo from Andrew McCormick's book called The Galloway Tinklers I hope it's ok. Had a bit of trouble making it smaller but hopefully it's alright now.

Judy

[ankerdine]

Oh, but you cannot read it. Sorry!

It's a William Marshall with his wife Katie O'Neil!! So who are these people and when were they around?

Judy