Willow I am sure we are going to find that your James and my Robert were brothers or at least cousins.
Robert m Mary Cooper 14 Aug 1797 Shifnal but had all their children in Wombridge so I think he must have been from Wombridge and she from Shifnal he must have been b before 1779 and your James was 1760 ish.
I am wondering if Lourdes' Thomas 1823 was in fact one of yours you have four between 1820 -1823 but you have accounted for all yours and Lourdes' Thomas 1823 does m Rosanna Mar qtr 1846 at the time she was the widow GLOVER. I can't find them 1851

I think the Robert and Caroline are a bit of a red herring as they don't marry until 1836 and appear to be both born 1816 from censuses. I am not even sure that its the same Caroline Armstrong but I cant find another either.
Trees really puzzled with this one