Hi Talmage
I have been looking for a definite birthplace for my great-great grandfather William Whitmore for the last 10 years or so when my Sister-in-Law came to an impasse in her genealogical research on my behalf. This was long before internet searching was available as a tool and she had to rely on source material such as Parish Registers, Poor Records, Census Returns, and Family Records Centres.
He was recorded on the Censuses as being born in 1816 in a place called "Care" in Ireland which as you know does not exist and we came to the conclusion that it must have been mis- recorded and that we would have to leave it on the back-burner due to the paucity of Irish Records. We were quite expecting having to look for Irish ancestry when everyone was in Reigate all along.
Well - you've guessed it. I was absolutely gobsmacked when on again Googling the Surname and Place of Birth yesterday, just in case, the first result that came up was your Baptism in Cahir enquiry from 2008! In your one paragraph it explained the whole Ireland / Reigate connection. I have always thought that it might involve army service.
My wife, who has now taken over genealogical matters, immediately set about expanding the data and making sure that your great-great grandfather (and indeed our great-great-great grandfathers) are one and the same. She has come up with a town that appears to have more than its fair share of Whitmores so the task could prove exhausting!
Did your subsequent research reveal where he was baptised? I am the great-grandson of Edwin Whitmore whose grand-daughter Edna Winifred Whitmore had me in 1946.
Thanks for your post which has removed a major stumbling block.