Fenwick's in Bingley?

[Wendy in W. Aust.]

My great Grand father was Edmund Fenwick, born 1853.  It seemed at first he was born in Hyde, Cheshire, but subsequent information suggests he might have been born in Lane Bottom, Micklethwaite, Bingley, Yorkshire.
If the Cheshire info is correct, his parents were Aaron Fenwick(1822) & Sarah Lee Tow(about 1828).
The family believe however that Bingley was the place of their roots, & the Cheshire information was a complete surprise.  Did they pop across the border quite frequently, just to confuse people like me?  Any suggestions for a befuddled great grand daughter from Western Australia?

[winston]

Hi

Where did you get the parents names from?

Just curious as this is your young man on the 1871 census and parents are the same. but ages are slightly out for Aaron

 Aaron Fenwick 39  Bingley, Yorkshire, England Head  Bingley  Yorkshire   
 Edmund Fenwick 18  Bingley, Yorkshire, England Son  Bingley  Yorkshire   
 Sarah Fenwick 41  Bingley, Yorkshire, England Wife  Bingley  Yorkshire   


Wendy