Dear Rosalie, I have looked up the Redcoats,and I may have given you the wrong information. There is certainly a Howarth who stayed in Sydney, but his name wasn't John, his wife wasn't Eliza, and he was married in 1848. This is one of the problems with Ancestry. People who are searching for ancestors, sometimes make assumptions, based on dodgy info., then post it on their Genealogy pages. Everything I find out, in my own research, is documented. The family who has posted John Howarth's stuff, has certainly put the info I said to you. Now there my be a second Howarth, who doesn't appear on the Redcoat Settler''s page, or the Redcoat person may have been given the wrong infformation, but it seems strange that the info is different. You might like to get in touch with the family and ask them. I have the same trouble with John Wilson, because on Ancestry, there are descendants who are adamant that he is a John Wilson who arrived in Adelaide in 1844, and I have done extensive research on both, and know that he is not. Such is life!Cheers, Fay