Carolyn,
Thank you so much for that post. It is full of detail, some tallying with my own records, some new.
I shall reply in full shortly when I have a bit more time and have checked my files.
Meantime I have a tree in front of me which has
John b.c 1848, Aberlady (to Janet), Groom/Coachman, sometime at Aberlady Mains Cottage, m. 1874, Salton,(sp?) to Elizabeth Young. I have eight children of theirs listed---tell me if you want details.
William b.c.1850 Flesher(Butcher), m.1873 N. Berwick, Mary Lindores, later manager at Limekilns, Catcraig, Dunbar. Eight children listed!
David b.c.1859 Flesher, m.1880, Aberlady,Douglas Graham (yes this a female name).
I have five offspring just pencilled in----need to check these details.
I shall look into the question of Mary Murphy/Margaret (Kilgour)
Have never been able to find the marriage certificate of William b.1794, d. 1877( my gt,gt,gt,grandfather) and Mary Robertson b. 1789, Aberlady. I suspect they belonged to the United Free Church.
Will give other info. soon.
Thanks again,
MairiD