Hi Hume
I think you're right. Thanks for the info on Jeremiah. The only suitably aged Alexr. I can find is one in Bothwell who is not of the family either so reckon it is a dead end -

.
I also wonder if Margaret called her sons born in 1833 and 1838 after two dead brothers as, as far as I can see, they are the only ones to have Paul as a middle name, ie Alexander Paul and Jeremiah Paul.
Since you know Limekilnburn so well (I have only been once to the area) I wonder if you know of a possible toll house near Broomleton/Glassford? That is where Agnes Paul set up house when she married Alexander Torrance. He was connected to the Crookedstane family. I think the Pauls may have moved to a tollhouse there. I hope you don't mind me asking.
Regards
Lorna