Place of birth different, but going by occupation and surname of those he is lodging with, I'd say this is John in 1851
HO107 2215 22 59
Fernhill , Bury
William Nuttall 31
Sarah Nuttall 29
Thomas son 6
john son 6 mths
William Nuttall lodger coal miner 22
John Mallalieu lodger 22 coal miner bn Cheshire hyde
there are also 2 other John Mallalieus of simlilar age on 1851 born in Yorkshire
This is not easy - there are more Mallawotnots about that one would think!