The 1891 is the right one Sarah Anne was my great grandmother
Thanks
Implying the previous ones are right too, given dad Jonathan is staying with them

Jonathan sr's wife was Sarah Humphries I believe (marriage Wolstanton RD Sep 1850)
Extracted IGI marriage:
Jonathon Shawcross (Father Joseph Shawcross)
to Sarah Humphries (Father Robert Humphries)
20 JUL 1850 Burslem St John, Staffordshire