Hi Jo, Deb and An65
You're too fast for me and you've done a great job. I can see you love a puzzle

THis is fantastic. Thank you so much.
Yes I'll order Henry's certificate to see if Dinah/Ellen is the informant - does look as if they weren't married doesn't it. Maybe that earlier Ann I found (if right of course) died. Also maybe the younger children were Dinah/Ellens and only the oldest two were Henry and Ann's.
The earlier Smiths - Christopher, Charlotte and C that Deb found, they look promising too .. It points to Bathwell maybe being also known as Matthew yes? I've a later link with Donington as Fred Smith (Henry's son) married Annie Luesby of Donington. And in an old family birthday book I've found the entry "Uncle Barthy died 1923 Donington)
I don't know of a grandson Herbert Smith (in 1901 census) - the first son I know of Fred Smith and Annie Luesby is Henry (Sonny) born 1905. There is a later son Felix . Several times another son has been mentioned in the family but not known for sure, so Herbert is a mystery to me. Maybe he is a son of one of Fred's siblings? The birth dates fall wrong between the census don't they so I don't think we'll know anymore on him until 1911 census.
So, I think my best bet now is to get Henry's death certificate and Bartholomew's marriage certificate yes? I'll let you know as soon as I get them.
Chez