Author Topic: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.  (Read 32371 times)

Offline Tricia_2

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,270
  • "Family ~ link to our past, bridge to our future"
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #27 on: Tuesday 24 June 08 11:23 BST (UK) »
My tree is on GenesReunited.

Obviously living people are not named, but I also decided not to name most of the people with 'children' living. I wasn't happy when a stranger put my Dad's details on their tree, even though he died a few years ago.

As for not doing the family history, I know that a friend of mine won't do hers because of 'skeletons' that she would prefer to be 'forgotten'.

When I announced to my grandparents that I was going to research our family tree, you could have cut the atmosphere with a knife. My parents got interested, too, but my grandmother was very much against it. It was, again, because of protecting people's memories ~ related to some illegitimacies, etc.

When we contacted a family, whom we believed we were connected to through an illegitimate line, we were accused of traducing memories, and I'm sure that I read that people could be arrested if they asked people for family history information and it upset them.

I was only talking to my Mum about this recently. Some of the info I discuss and post would have upset my grandparents terribly. Perhaps I am disrespecting their memories ~ memories of people who I loved & who loved me ~ by doing this. However, I do think that attitudes have changed and that they would appreciate this ~ and that they would (maybe did) say that it was ok to do it after their deaths.

I love my hobby and don't plan to give it up ~ but I can see both sides.
I can certainly understand why people mighht be wary of posting things on the Internet. However, it is a very effective way of 'finding relatives ~ and, so far, I haven't encountered any major problems.
Worcs / Glos: Neal Neale Jeynes Jeens Geans Harris Roper Ropier Colley Dyer Heeks Bayzand Hampton Bishop Cole Elton Littlehales McGowan
Glamorgam: Hampton Thornton Svombo Swambo Swanbo Keefe O Keefe Shanahan Shannon Doyle Maldoon Muldoon Davies Llewellyn Jones
Birmingham: Neale Sarjant Cole Hiley Berridge Tirebuck

Offline JeanH

  • I am sorry but my email address is no longer working
  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 524
  • We are all products of our past
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #28 on: Tuesday 24 June 08 11:38 BST (UK) »
I have the reverse of your problem.  A "relation" of ours contacted me and demanded to be given all the reseach I had on a part of my tree.  I had not heard from this relation in 30 years.  When I objected to just handing over my hard earned work the reply was that as it was their family too they had a legal right to it.  I agreed, and told them to do what I had done, obtain relevant certificates, trawl round the Local History sections and Registry  Offices, join various Family History Groups, pay to go on line and access census.  I recieved quite a lot of abuse from the relation as a result.  It was so sad, as I would have willingly collaborated with this person to gather even more information which could be passed on.  No way now would I ever give them my research.  Maeve
Yorkshire - Herbert - Phelps - Brain - Baxter - Crowther - Gillen - Rhodes - Ambler - Norton - Robinson - Gloucestershire - Herbert - Phelps - Brain
Suffolk - Clarke

Offline LizzieW

  • RootsChat Marquessate
  • *******
  • Posts: 11,036
  • I'm nearer to finding out who you are thanks DNA
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #29 on: Tuesday 24 June 08 12:29 BST (UK) »
Most of my family and cousins etc. are very interested in the family history I have found, although there are parts I have not divulged to the cousins on my dad's side of the tree, but that is mainly because one of my dad's sisters is still alive (in her 90s) and I'm not sure if she knows what I found out about her father.

Lizzie

ps.  If my dad was alive, I would have told him what I'd found out about his father, he would have thought it very funny, as he didn't really get on with his dad who was apparently a bit of a bully.

Offline Siamese Girl

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,246
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #30 on: Tuesday 24 June 08 17:14 BST (UK) »
I tend to work with a loose cut off date - ancestors say from gt grandparents back while the more recent ones are relatives. My ancestors are in the public domain (so to speak) but the relatives are family and so aren't, unless they are happy to be so.

Carole
CHILD Glos/London, BONUS London, DIMSDALE London, HODD and TUTT Sussex,  BONNER and PATTEN Essex, BOWLER and HOLLIER Oxfordshire, HUGH Lincolnshire, LEEDOM all.


Offline newby dee

  • RootsChat Senior
  • ****
  • Posts: 417
  • Census information Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #31 on: Tuesday 24 June 08 23:07 BST (UK) »
my mother introduced me to family history years before it became fashionable and she is the most private person i have ever met and very introvert (i love her to bits though and am total opposite)
so dont understand your sisters objection .. just carry on enjoy it and if she ever asks offer any info you have.....
most of all enjoy and best of luck with your searches...
and if you find a cure for habit please share Ha ha
PUTTNAM..london..olney..
POWELL...treorchy
WALL...bath
STAPLES...weston-super-mare..bleadon...
PEPPIATT...llondon
TULLETT (hannah) born cork ireland... 1891 census living london
WILLIAMS....rhyl wales

Offline johngirl

  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 902
  • My Dad and his cousins.
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #32 on: Tuesday 24 June 08 23:28 BST (UK) »
Hi,
  yes I have found quite a few children born before marriage, a murder and a few suicides but really who cares some family's have even more skeletons than our family. I also was only putting in passed on relatives and put no information about the living. The family history is something I wanted to do which my sister was all for when I started doing it. So with everybody's comments and words of encouragement Iam still plugging on with it. B*****ger my sister. She will now have to grovel if she wants any part of this. My sister will be told the same thing Maeve told her lovely cousin! Go find the information yourself.

             Johngirl ;D ;D
JOHN- Pembrokeshire Wales.  FREEMAN -England?
MEDLICOT -Monmouthshire Wales.
ISAAC -Gloucestershire and Liverpool.[Toxteth Park] SNOW- England .Convict. FRAZER- England.Convict.
DEAL -Ireland .Convict.
KEMP -Saint Mary Cray Kent.Eynsford Wilmington England.Convict.
BLACKBERRY -Whitechapel .Convict. CONDON -alias
DUFFY-Brighton England. Convict.
BANTICK -Ixworth Sussex England. Convict.
JONES England????[George]Convict.
ROSE-England. Convict.
All came to Tas

Offline Tricia_2

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,270
  • "Family ~ link to our past, bridge to our future"
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #33 on: Wednesday 25 June 08 10:29 BST (UK) »
I love the way that family history can draw families together ~ and we find new relatives all the time. It's sad if it causes a family rift.
Worcs / Glos: Neal Neale Jeynes Jeens Geans Harris Roper Ropier Colley Dyer Heeks Bayzand Hampton Bishop Cole Elton Littlehales McGowan
Glamorgam: Hampton Thornton Svombo Swambo Swanbo Keefe O Keefe Shanahan Shannon Doyle Maldoon Muldoon Davies Llewellyn Jones
Birmingham: Neale Sarjant Cole Hiley Berridge Tirebuck

Offline Siamese Girl

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,246
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #34 on: Wednesday 25 June 08 11:21 BST (UK) »
I love the way that family history can draw families together ~ and we find new relatives all the time. It's sad if it causes a family rift.

It can be difficult if you disprove long held to be true stories or come up with too many black sheep - what is adding colour to one person can be destroying another person's cherished ideas about their grandparents or a much loved great aunt/uncle  :(

Carole
CHILD Glos/London, BONUS London, DIMSDALE London, HODD and TUTT Sussex,  BONNER and PATTEN Essex, BOWLER and HOLLIER Oxfordshire, HUGH Lincolnshire, LEEDOM all.

Offline Dancing Master

  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 552
  • Census information Crown Copyright, from www.nationalarchives.gov.uk
    • View Profile
Re: My sister doesn`t want me to do the family history.
« Reply #35 on: Wednesday 25 June 08 19:49 BST (UK) »
Perhaps she feels you have put too recent information online, which could have some detrimental effect on her and/or her own part of the family.

I never post my family tree online, I work on it and I have it in a programme but it is for personal use.   Yet a distant cousin has put online information which is too close to home to be comfortable about.  including dob. of living family complete with addresses and other personal information.

I don't even keep my Family Tree information on the computer I use to go online either.

Maybe she does know something that she doesn't want in the public domain.   Its a personal choice thing.