I have just spent two hours going through the records of all the men mentioned above. What an amazing resource.
I now know that Robert Howe was barely taller than I am, at 5'3" and weighing in at only nine stones. Very like my grandfather, his younger brother, who was tiny and slightly built. Frederick Arthur Howe was a bit of a rebel and was court martialled and sentenced to one hundred days confinement. His brother, Robert, in a letter, said that he considered Frederick to be "mentally not all there" after the war. Hardly surprising, though he did live for many years after his discharge in 1919.
As for James Shaw Howe, the description of him makes me think he looked like his father, my great grandfather, being 5'6" and over eleven stones, with a florid complexion. He proved to be an elusive character as far as Mrs Tulloch and her sister were concerned. She was persistent in her attempts to find him and I can only think that the authorities must have been heartily fed up with her letters!
On the last page of documents refering to James Shaw Howe, it says that a memorial plaque was sent to his mother, Mrs C Howe, in Aberdeen. That same plaque, treasured and highly polished, is in my mother's fireplace, along with a load of rather ordinary horse brasses. There are not many of her possessions which I covet but...............!
I should still like to find out more about Robert and Frederick's post war lives so if anyone out there knows anything, please get in touch. It seems my father's cousin was not right about Robert's occupation but I have discovered that he was actually in Melbourne in 1934.
Jen