Michael,
Thank you this does help.
I thought the use of John for illegitimacy didn't sound right, but thought I'd check it out, particularly as my GGG grandfather on the other side is also illegitimate, but his birth record states, Jonathan illegitimate son of Sarah Richardson
Yes Michael married Ann Postle in Shotley Bridge 1837 and her father was Jonathan - her mother is a bit of an issue. Her parish baptism records says,
Baptisms, Lanchester District
Record Number: 407332.0
Parish/Church: Medomsley (St. Mary Magdalene)
17 Oct 1819 Ann Postle, of Shotley Bridge, daughter of Jonathan Postle (husbandman) by his wife Mary.
but Jonathan also had a number of children before Ann with Rebecca Forster - I don't know where the Mary has come from. It's definitely the same Jonatahn Postle on teh parish record. The Rebecca fits in with Michael and Ann naming their first daughter Rebecca.
Michael and Ann named their children, Rebecca b1839, Jonathan b1844, John b1851, Joseph b1855 and Michael Henry b1859. I haven't looked to see if there have been any deaths in between, but all these children appear on all census's from 1841 onwards.
Using your format Michaels dad should have been called John or Jonathan (shortened to John maybe?).
You're also right, I can't find any children of Michael and Ann named Margaret, although it does appear that they only had the one daughter.
You seem to know what you're on about, so just how reliable is the IGI index ? Some people tell me that it's very reliabll and I should give up looking for a fther for Michael and assume that this entry in St John Lee is definitely him, but now I'm being told that it's not a reliable source.
I'm still relatively new to this. I can find my way around the census and BMDs, but am not so sure about parish records, and living so far away I can't really get to records offices.
Thanks very much for your help and advice.
Nadine