Hello Colin,
Many thanks for your work on my behalf regarding HESTER JUDD.
Upon further thought, I must agree that Esther James and Esther Judd being the same person is looking unlikely.
WILLIAM & MARY ANNE JUDD in Endless Street plus 3 baptisms is interesting. Could this be the William who married Mary Ann Gray 10/4/1806 at Netherhampton, followed by the baptism of their daughter Elizabeth 22/7/1811 also at Netherhampton ?
Then there is the William who married Mary Ann Bell in 1824 at Whiteparish. They appear in 1841 to be living at Broughton, Hants, where his occupation is given as "Dealer"
That said, are there any other local Williams not necessarily married to a Mary Ann ? As I only have WILLIAM for Hester's father - but I'm unsure of her Mother's name.
I suppose it's also possible that HESTER wasn't actually born in Salisbury, but merely that her earliest recollections were of living in the"Close" area.
Your suggestion and reasoning regarding Emma does sound good. I have sent for the will of William Judd the butcher, hoping that it may shed some light. If anything positive comes from that, I will let you know.
Just as an aside, ESTHER / HESTER JUDD & FRED LIDDALL were both residing at Marlborough College when they married 4/3/1849. However, in 1851 they have returned to live at East Harnham. Just along the road from there in the Alderbury Union Workhouse are 3 JUDD orphan girls (Jane 16, Ellen 13, Winifred 5, all born at Fisherton). Could this be coincidence ? Or is it possible they may be her siblings / relatives, and she keeping an eye on them.
I'm still searching.
Thanks and kind regards, Alan.