Hi there
There are 2 Charles Peters born 1858-1859 Plymouth on the 1871 census:
1871 Census - Plymouth Burough, St. Andrew, Devon
Union Place
Charles Peters, age 12 born Plymouth
Father: John Peters, age 52, Blacksmith, born Plymouth, Devon,
Mother: Elizabeth Peters, age 49, born Plymouth
John H. Peters, age 20, Printer, born Plymouth
Elizabeth A. Peters, age 17, Book folder, born Plymouth
Emma Peters, age 14, General Servant, born Plymouth
1871 Census, St. Mary's Church, Devon
Charles W. Peters, age 13, born St. Andrews, Plymouth
Father: John W. Peters age 35, Baker, born Kingswear
Mother: Mary A. Peters, age 36, born St Mary's Church
Thomas H., age 12, St. Mary's Church
Florence, age 3, St. Mary's Church
According the the FreeBMD:
Elizabeth Bertha Crabb birth registered Jan-Mar 1857 in the Chard District
Charles Edward Peters registered Plymouth, Devon, Jan to March 1859;
and a Charles William Peters registered in Plymouth, Jul-Sep 1858
I checked the FreeBMD for Elizabeth Crabb and Charles Peters and found:
Charles Edward Peters and Elizabeth Crabb
marriage registered Apr-Jun 1885 Bideford
volume 5b, page 920
So, you can forget about the Charles William listed above.
You can order the birth and marriage certs here
http://www.gro.gov.uk/gro/content/certificates/Good luck in your research
