The cattle stealing guy was 47 in 1845 making him born 1795 also said a labourer. The one in the 58th foot was still in the army then - discharged 1853, so cannot be him. The one who died aged 50 in 1870 would have been born 1820 - granted only 3yrs out. I will try and see what the TNA have on the 58th foot reg for the time period concerned. But as I cannot find anything further on my one born/bapt 1817 leads me to believe he may have gone abroad, possibly with the army/navy etc. Now this one in the 58th foot, I don't have any more info on him at the moment, ie his age etc, so it could be him??