Hi Wendy,
I'm afraid not both have about the same information here is the 1851
HO107/1738 fo165 p10 ed: Hardingstone Hardingstone 2b
pt: Hardingstone, EccD: , cb: , t: , v:
sch:35 Beer House / Earth House
The family entry continues to p 11 where there are two entries for barges
(His brother is on p11 on one of the barges) address Coton End Grand Junnction Warf Yard
Hope this helps